This is one of the most important discussions we can have in the US presently. It is a fact that everyone who is undocumented is illegally here, having intentionally broken federal immigration laws. All of Mr. Muse's arguments are valid, in my opinion. Additionally, anyone familiar with policing in America can tell you that many criminals - especially Blue states or cities - are not prosecuted ever, even for violent crimes. If we go by arrest rates (and the fact that only two states require documented immigrant status makes this very difficult to prove), the criminality of illegal aliens is very high. As an aside, my sister was a Child Protection Services case worker. She said that child abuse and molestation among the illegal communities was very, very high. Ending illegal immigration, to the degree that is possible, and deporting the 20 -30+ million already here, while passing the SAVE Act to ensure more honest elections, is a battle for the future of this country. Illegal status should = automatic deportation save the very, very few political refugees.
Ann Coulter noted in Adios America, published more than a decade ago, that it was virtually impossible to get true stats on illegal immigrant crime. Your methodology here is really eye-opening. Until all cities, counties, and states begin keeping stats on illegal alien crime, weβll have to collect clues from all the sources you noted. Really good work here!
Crime data isnβt magic β it reflects what you count and what you ignore. If deportations remove offenders from the sampling frame, if plea deals compress charges into immigration violations, and if underreporting suppresses victimization statistics, then headline comparisons deserve scrutiny. Public policy should rest on transparent methodology, not talking points. That means distinguishing between citizens, lawful immigrants, and those here unlawfully β and being clear about which offenses are included. It also means resisting blanket claims that inflame rather than inform. Immigration enforcement is a legitimate debate. So is data integrity. But serious reform requires honest accounting, not selective statistics or partisan caricatures.
This is a good argument but I look at it a different way. It is irrelevant to me if illegal aliens commit more or less crime than citizens, so no, it doesnβt shut down the βimmigrants commit less crimeβ argument. We have enough criminals among the citizen population and do not need to import more.
Crimes aside, they are here uninvited, they are dependent on taxpayer citizens to support them, they really do not contribute to the country, so they must go..
This is one of the most important discussions we can have in the US presently. It is a fact that everyone who is undocumented is illegally here, having intentionally broken federal immigration laws. All of Mr. Muse's arguments are valid, in my opinion. Additionally, anyone familiar with policing in America can tell you that many criminals - especially Blue states or cities - are not prosecuted ever, even for violent crimes. If we go by arrest rates (and the fact that only two states require documented immigrant status makes this very difficult to prove), the criminality of illegal aliens is very high. As an aside, my sister was a Child Protection Services case worker. She said that child abuse and molestation among the illegal communities was very, very high. Ending illegal immigration, to the degree that is possible, and deporting the 20 -30+ million already here, while passing the SAVE Act to ensure more honest elections, is a battle for the future of this country. Illegal status should = automatic deportation save the very, very few political refugees.
Excellent! Thank you for exposing the false methodology behind this claim.
Well, they started deporting people, and everywhere it was done, crime dropped. ππ
Narrative stats are nonsense.
Exactly, which proves that illegals commit more crimes than citizens.
Bottom line: if you want the truth about ANYTHING these days you have to go search for it.
Otherwise youβre just prey for the blizzard of lies blowing all around and trying to bury you.
Whether it's counting residents for the census or criminal aliens for the MSM, accuracy is the least consideration.
No surprise!
Fabulous job.
Ann Coulter noted in Adios America, published more than a decade ago, that it was virtually impossible to get true stats on illegal immigrant crime. Your methodology here is really eye-opening. Until all cities, counties, and states begin keeping stats on illegal alien crime, weβll have to collect clues from all the sources you noted. Really good work here!
Democrats lie constantly.
Crime data isnβt magic β it reflects what you count and what you ignore. If deportations remove offenders from the sampling frame, if plea deals compress charges into immigration violations, and if underreporting suppresses victimization statistics, then headline comparisons deserve scrutiny. Public policy should rest on transparent methodology, not talking points. That means distinguishing between citizens, lawful immigrants, and those here unlawfully β and being clear about which offenses are included. It also means resisting blanket claims that inflame rather than inform. Immigration enforcement is a legitimate debate. So is data integrity. But serious reform requires honest accounting, not selective statistics or partisan caricatures.
Democrats do not believe the first duty of the American government is to protect the American people.
Studies have shown they'd commit fewer crimes after being beheaded.
This is a good argument but I look at it a different way. It is irrelevant to me if illegal aliens commit more or less crime than citizens, so no, it doesnβt shut down the βimmigrants commit less crimeβ argument. We have enough criminals among the citizen population and do not need to import more.
Great point!
Crimes aside, they are here uninvited, they are dependent on taxpayer citizens to support them, they really do not contribute to the country, so they must go..
Thanks for that very well-researched and detailed explanation. Bottom line, 100% are criminals for having entered illegally.
Definitely time for consequences!!
DUH!