10 Comments
User's avatar
Richard Luthmann's avatar

Midterms don’t hinge only on models. They hinge on mood. The wild card is whether spring and summer unrest explodes again in deep-blue cities the way it did in 2020. If crime spikes, protests turn destructive, and governors hesitate while mayors equivocate, suburban persuadables will not parse turnout spreadsheets — they’ll react viscerally. Law and order still moves swing voters. If blue-state leadership appears unable or unwilling to maintain basic civic stability, that becomes a national referendum. Prediction markets can price probabilities, but televised chaos rewrites them overnight. The X factor isn’t polling. It’s whether America sees another summer of burning storefronts.

Jerri Hinojosa's avatar

Your answer seems correct to me, a rational human. Two things make me equivocate. 1. There is a scary number of people whose facility with logic goes this far: “If there’s burning and looting during Trump’s presidency, the solution is to go back a party who had no burning and looting”

2. Many Republicans are feeling like spanking the Senate for their poor production, especially the outright intransigence on the Save Act.

I fashion myself more rational than the people in #1, but I’m not sure I’m going to be able to hold my nose and vote for some republicans who are counterproductive.

Suzie's avatar

Not holding your nose for a stinky Republican is tantamount to just voting for the Democrat. That’s BITING your nose off to spite your face. Waiting for the perfect candidate is simply not an option.

I will vote for the Republican on the ticket no matter how stinky they are because the alternative is deliberately choosing national suicide.

Apathy in these midterms by Republican voters will kill this country. This is no time for anyone to think they can sit this out.

Jerri Hinojosa's avatar

I almost used that metaphor in my post to say “I’ve followed the logic of ‘don’t cut off your nose to spite your own face’ too many times.” I won’t sit home because I always vote, but I’m not so quick to vote a straight Republican ticket anymore. Sometimes we may have to let an entrenched Mitch McConnell acolyte like John Cornyn get defeated by a Democrat so a real America First Republican has a chance in the next republican primary. Also, when you can almost count on John Fetterman more than John Thune to represent your interests, you have to question conventional logic.

Suzie's avatar

Assuming there’d be a “next time” should the Dems ever regain power. You underestimate the depths and breadth and lengths they will go to make sure Republicans are destroyed if they ever get back in. They’ve come right out and said as much, like Susan Rice just did the other day.

curt s sanders's avatar

Totally agree, Richard..! Volatility is the name of the game right now and if the lefty loonies turn protests violent and destructive Americans will not be voting out the Trump agenda of law and order..

c Anderson's avatar

Never forgetting, of course, James Carville’s, “It’s the economy, Stupid.” We need the Trump tariff rebates.